Stretchmarks on a rock cabbage
Nov. 21st, 2009 10:37 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
imomusKrautrock - the Rebirth of Germany is a BBC4 documentary on the mystical electronic music British rock critics dubbed "Krautrock" (which is a bit like calling Alberto Camerini a "Woprocker"). Directed by Ben Whalley, the film is a companion to the one I linked the other day about UK synthpop, Synth Britannia.
[Error: unknown template video]
Does anyone else see the influence of Adam Curtis here? The voice-over sounds a bit Curtis-like, and Whalley has a similar approach to selecting and editing clips. Whenever I think of Adam Curtis I think of the artist Luke Fowler's documentaries, which seem to have headed even further out in the same direction. Like Curtis, Fowler selects dramatic, texturally-interesting clips -- glimpses of radical sixties and seventies subcultures. Whalley does the same thing: his very short clip of Kraftwerk dancing, for instance, is masterfully placed as a glimpse that leaves you wanting more.
[Error: unknown template video]
If documentaries move more in this direction it's not hard to imagine them employing an interesting and successful rule Fowler sets himself to keep his textures consistent, and his subjects consistently mythical: never show people as they look today. Watching these documentaries, it's hard not to be distracted by counting the lines on Iggy Pop's stomach or regretting the fact that a surviving member of Popol Vuh who looks as if he's undergoing chemotherapy is lighting up cigarettes on camera. We could say that all documentaries about cool and charismatic subcultures are doomed to a basically bathetic narrative structure (it's nature's very own bathos, but that shouldn't excuse it) when they balance young, good looking, cool people against the prunes they inevitably become. The viewer is forced into playing a constant game of Spot the Difference, rather than experiencing the full revelation of an aesthetic revolution at its peak. The end result is a sort of temporal embourgeoisement. "Don't worry," this narrative structure seems to say "we all go slack and paunchy in the end. Even the visionaries."
[Error: unknown template video]
Then again, there is a fascination in discovering that venues which are part of past legend are also part of your regular experience. Before watching this documentary I didn't realise that the Zodiak Arts Club, a Berlin experimental arts centre founded by Hans-Joachim Roedelius of Cluster, is what I know today as HAU2, part of the Hebbel-am-Ufer theatre complex in Kreuzberg where we watched the Tokio Shibuya theatre season last month.
[Error: unknown template video]
There are other niggling critiques you could make of the Krautrock doc. The presence of Iggy Pop and the absence of Eno, for instance, is odd. Julian Cope could usefully have popped up at some point. They could have employed a critic to sift bad records of the period from good. Kraftwerk is arguably over-familiar and part of a different genre.
[Error: unknown template video]
Then there's the questionable scene-setting at the beginning, where footage of 1968 student disturbances in Berlin is played while the script tells us that pop music in Germany at the time was Schlager, which said nothing about "the reality of what was happening on the streets". If the documentarists are trying to set up a "Punk swept away Prog" sort of scenario, they're barking up the wrong tree. First of all, Schlager is still with us; its audience of working class Germans in kniepes doesn't overlap with the Krautrock audience at all. Secondly, Krautrock has as little relevance to urban political uprisings as Schlager has; it's a music of mystical introspection, for the most part recorded in country barns.
[Error: unknown template video]
Grousing aside, though, this is a very interesting film, and I'd like to see BBC4 continue to employ Ben Whalley. They should also think about screening Luke Fowler's film about Cornelius Cardew, Pilgrimage from Scattered Points, though, because Fowler shows how a documentary about a visionary artist can, itself, be visionary art. It's a good deal more uplifting than counting Iggy Pop's stretchmarks.
[Error: unknown template video]
Does anyone else see the influence of Adam Curtis here? The voice-over sounds a bit Curtis-like, and Whalley has a similar approach to selecting and editing clips. Whenever I think of Adam Curtis I think of the artist Luke Fowler's documentaries, which seem to have headed even further out in the same direction. Like Curtis, Fowler selects dramatic, texturally-interesting clips -- glimpses of radical sixties and seventies subcultures. Whalley does the same thing: his very short clip of Kraftwerk dancing, for instance, is masterfully placed as a glimpse that leaves you wanting more.
[Error: unknown template video]
If documentaries move more in this direction it's not hard to imagine them employing an interesting and successful rule Fowler sets himself to keep his textures consistent, and his subjects consistently mythical: never show people as they look today. Watching these documentaries, it's hard not to be distracted by counting the lines on Iggy Pop's stomach or regretting the fact that a surviving member of Popol Vuh who looks as if he's undergoing chemotherapy is lighting up cigarettes on camera. We could say that all documentaries about cool and charismatic subcultures are doomed to a basically bathetic narrative structure (it's nature's very own bathos, but that shouldn't excuse it) when they balance young, good looking, cool people against the prunes they inevitably become. The viewer is forced into playing a constant game of Spot the Difference, rather than experiencing the full revelation of an aesthetic revolution at its peak. The end result is a sort of temporal embourgeoisement. "Don't worry," this narrative structure seems to say "we all go slack and paunchy in the end. Even the visionaries."
[Error: unknown template video]
Then again, there is a fascination in discovering that venues which are part of past legend are also part of your regular experience. Before watching this documentary I didn't realise that the Zodiak Arts Club, a Berlin experimental arts centre founded by Hans-Joachim Roedelius of Cluster, is what I know today as HAU2, part of the Hebbel-am-Ufer theatre complex in Kreuzberg where we watched the Tokio Shibuya theatre season last month.
[Error: unknown template video]
There are other niggling critiques you could make of the Krautrock doc. The presence of Iggy Pop and the absence of Eno, for instance, is odd. Julian Cope could usefully have popped up at some point. They could have employed a critic to sift bad records of the period from good. Kraftwerk is arguably over-familiar and part of a different genre.
[Error: unknown template video]
Then there's the questionable scene-setting at the beginning, where footage of 1968 student disturbances in Berlin is played while the script tells us that pop music in Germany at the time was Schlager, which said nothing about "the reality of what was happening on the streets". If the documentarists are trying to set up a "Punk swept away Prog" sort of scenario, they're barking up the wrong tree. First of all, Schlager is still with us; its audience of working class Germans in kniepes doesn't overlap with the Krautrock audience at all. Secondly, Krautrock has as little relevance to urban political uprisings as Schlager has; it's a music of mystical introspection, for the most part recorded in country barns.
[Error: unknown template video]
Grousing aside, though, this is a very interesting film, and I'd like to see BBC4 continue to employ Ben Whalley. They should also think about screening Luke Fowler's film about Cornelius Cardew, Pilgrimage from Scattered Points, though, because Fowler shows how a documentary about a visionary artist can, itself, be visionary art. It's a good deal more uplifting than counting Iggy Pop's stretchmarks.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-21 10:45 am (UTC)I feel like I'm ready to fly the coop.
stretchmarks
Date: 2009-11-21 12:43 pm (UTC)"...Or you're looking at an exuberant grotesque, part-clown part-reptile - death-denying or death taunting and in any case, somehow in a state of avoidance concerning the fact that this body is 60, the face like an astonished and jubilant skull that has just watched its own reconstruction thru surgery..."
http://www.timetchells.com/notebook/june-2007/boundless/
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-21 12:54 pm (UTC)I was once interviewed for a work experience with the Panorama documentary unit. Curtis's name didn't carry a lot of currency in the interview, which doesn't come as a surprise because Panorama blows.
I shall re-peruse it. I do love the krautrock.
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-21 02:03 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-21 02:24 pm (UTC)Sour krauts
Date: 2009-11-21 03:00 pm (UTC)By the way, all the Germans I know (relatives and friends) call themselves "krauts" with great ironic affection, which I guess at least deflects British disdain.
Z.
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-21 04:01 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 02:10 am (UTC)art wave
Date: 2009-11-21 06:49 pm (UTC)Re: art wave
Date: 2009-11-22 04:07 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-21 07:05 pm (UTC)Eno does not crop up as a talking head, but he is referred to by Cluster, with (if I remember correctly) Moebius at one point inferring that Eno appropriated their ideas and did not make good on expressed intentions regarding proposed recording projects.
It is curious that Cope also fail to appear as a commentator, he was a huge champion of Krautrock at a point when the movement (not that it was ever a movement in any real sense) was still largely overlooked in the UK.
Apropos of sifting good records from bad, what are your personal favourite Krautrock albums/artists Momus?
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 02:07 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 01:46 pm (UTC)The Eno/Cluster collaboration was the - rather obvious - attraction.
Like most Krautrock records, it most certainly isn't rock, the term is a clumsy and unfortunate misnomer.
Likewise I have the Kraftwerk albums and similarly consider their studio-produced, electronic classicism quite a different thing from the barnyard-experimentalism that seems to be the roots of Krautrock.
Otherwise have Can's Tago Mago, Cluster's Grosses Wasser and..ermm that's about it.
Fortunately this documentary has given some pointers toward future exploratory music purchases.
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-23 03:14 am (UTC)I've never associated faces with any of this music, so it surprised me to see how old these musicians are now, too! I must admit that although I am several generations removed from the Vaterland, the BBC's decision to conduct interviews in the most stereotypical biergarten possible, complete with chubby women wearing Eva Braun braids, made me cringe. (Now, why doesn't some wealthy benefactor supply Momus with a barn somewhere in the Black Forest for a few months so he really could produce a slow, pastoral, enigmatically beautiful album?)
Concerning the "Synth Brittania" documentary: does Britain have only one pop/rock critic? Does the BBC only own one film of Eno playing in Roxy Music? Was there no way to get the loquacious Marc Almond to speak? Has John Foxx turned into Sir George Martin? Well, at least such shows are produced in Britain; I can't imagine public television doing any documentaries remotely like these in the US.
Don't respond to any of this! We'd rather hear all about Warsaw...
recommended!
Date: 2009-11-21 11:55 pm (UTC)Re: recommended!
Date: 2009-11-22 02:03 am (UTC)Re: recommended!
Date: 2009-11-22 10:39 am (UTC)Would be interesting to read something by you on age and ageing (which might include the experience of losing one's contemporaries). I would imagine that most of your friends are younger than you (in that, we are the same) and that raises its own particular issues too. It even happens on this blog. I wondered, as I read with amusement your initially provocative and eventually exhausted sounding replies to the insane feminist during your last post, whether there is something draining about hanging about with people who are still full of the one-dimensional (and untested by life) convictions of the young? Of course the old can be draining too, but for different reasons.
Realise that your answer may well be that the whole blog is in effect a meditation on the process of getting older - and there might be some truth in that - but a piece that specifically acknowledges your own experiences of physical decline and what you think the future holds might be fascinating.
JS
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 02:24 am (UTC)im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-22 05:38 am (UTC)Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-22 08:26 am (UTC)Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-22 09:34 am (UTC)Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-22 09:38 am (UTC)Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-23 06:23 am (UTC)Vinyl Solution
Date: 2009-11-23 07:26 am (UTC)Do they prefer Dizzee Rascal or Lenny Kravitz?
Does Hitler prefer Vampire Weekend, or The Strokes?
The world needs to know.
Re: Vinyl Solution
Date: 2009-11-23 09:36 am (UTC)kraftwerk and its part in german culture/history is actually part of the initial entry, remember?
Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-22 12:05 pm (UTC)Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-23 06:20 am (UTC)your analogy would only make sense if the documentary in question was about different cheeses who professed to have been making themselves antithetical to the nazis of days past.
i have no fucking idea what "we" have to do with it, either. the comment was addressing whether or not the makers of this music were, in fact, creating something undesirable to said nazis.
Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-23 08:26 pm (UTC)Re: im the operator with my pocket calculator
Date: 2009-11-24 01:47 am (UTC)the grateful dead, on the other hand, they would have considered faggy and decadent and indulgent.
the nazis wanted people to be apollonian robots, not acid eating dionysians.
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 01:03 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 02:47 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 03:30 pm (UTC)Actually, when I watch these things I think - hey, that Nick Currie would be good at this - you could be the new Sister Wendy (obviously with a broader remit) ... the eyepatch; the 'weird' clothes, that mellifluous voice you've got ...
you'd be a BBC4 hit; you would! Plus, you know, people working in the arts bit of the Beeb probably know who you are now ... new generation - whereas, in the past, they didn't. Seriously - it'd be great to have you doing something on the Beeb, on Japan or whatever.
(no subject)
Date: 2009-11-22 04:18 pm (UTC)'The Unreliable Tour Guide In ... [Berlin, Tokyo, Warsaw, New York ... etc]'
People would love it. - you're as smart as Jonathan Meades so why not?
zuurkool met vette jus
Date: 2009-11-22 01:51 pm (UTC)